Slow convergence of the number of near-maxima for Burr XII distributions

A near-maximum is an observation which falls within a distance a of the maximum observation in an independent and identically distributed sample of size n. Subject to some conditions on the tail thickness of the population distribution, the number Kn(a) of nearmaxima is known to converge in probability to one or infinity, or in distribution to a shifted geometric law. In this paper we show that for all Burr XII distributions Kn(a) converges almost surely to unity, but this convergence property may not become clear under certain cases even for very large n. We explore the reason of such slow convergence by studying a distributional continuity between Burr XII and Weibull distributions. We have also given a theoretical explanation of slow convergence of Kn(a) for the Burr XII distributions by showing that the rate of convergence in terms of P {Kn(a) > 1} tending to zero changes very little with the sample size n. Illustrations of the limiting behaviour Kn(a) for the Burr XII and the Weibull distributions are given by simulations and real data. The study also raises an important issue that although the Burr XII provides overall better fit to a given data set than the Weibull distribution, cautions should be taken for the extrapolation of the upper tail behaviour in the case of slow convergence.